Source => uproxx.com
It’s usually been stated that pop music is formulaic — or, extra just lately algorithmic, as a result of the zeitgeist — however when a Twitter consumer posted a video of himself enjoying songs from The Weeknd on a mini-piano, customers on the app went nuts debating simply how true of the Canadian singer’s catalog that aphorism is.
The consumer in query was Andrew Huang, a self-declared “music human” who’s best-known for his “Tune Problem” video collection on YouTube (paradoxically, he too is Canadian, from Ottawa). Identified for making music with unconventional instruments and strategies, Huang posted a video enjoying the chord progressions of songs from The Weeknd’s catalog, positing within the caption, “Each Weeknd track makes use of the identical four notes.” The songs performed included “Inform Your Buddies” and “Usually” from Beauty Behind The Madness, “Reminder” and “Starboy” from Starboy, and “Heartless” from After Hours.
It didn’t take lengthy for followers to rev up their greatest arguments for whether or not the video was correct, inaccurate, good, or dangerous. Numerous replies defined why The Weeknd does this in musical idea phrases, with one clarifying that ‘the person discovered his key signature” and declaring “some Broadway singers even have components written particularly for them of their prefered key signatures.”
so the person discovered his key signature.. some broadway singers even have components written particularly for them of their prefered key signatures
— Mikee (@sceneboiimikee) September 16, 2020
To be honest each artist has a register and key they’re most comfy in, weeknd simply occurred to make use of that reality to his benefit can’t knock the hustle, pop smoke even has a variety of frequent key signatures and motivs, it’s not an unusual factor for artists
— Noka (@8n0Ka8) September 17, 2020
Others had some enjoyable with the vanity, utilizing it to make enjoyable of each pop music and its critics, whereas others used it to criticize what they perceived as a scarcity of songwriting development from The Weeknd, regardless of his ever-increasing reputation. There’s a reasonably good pun in there too.
Music critics: Each pop track makes use of solely 4 chords.
The weekend: Maintain my beer.
— Ben Feddersen (@SnoozeButtonBen) September 16, 2020
He is been rewriting Home of Balloons time and again for a decade and it retains working 🤷♂️
— Defund Police (Pusher) (@itsPusher) September 16, 2020
It is the weeknd, writing one other melody could be work and weeknds aren’t for work.
— Ciren Tune (@CirenSong) September 16, 2020
Nonetheless others simply used the chance to marvel on the expertise and hidden complexity of songwriters like The Weeknd and the truth that they’re able to create a lot range with only a handful of notes (there are solely so many keys, chords, and sounds the human mind can interpret as music, but we’vve been reinterpreting them for hundreds of years and so they all sound completely different — largely). In the meantime, one responder summed up the hype in a single intelligent commentary, remarking that whereas Huang by no means gave commentary on this tendency by The Weeknd, Twitter commenters have rivaled songwriters of their skill to show mainly something into an argument.
I fuckin love how music permits for infinite recontextualization of actually easy stuff and it nonetheless can sound utterly distinctive
— BLΣ▲Ok ⚪⚫ (@bleaksbeats) September 16, 2020
one of the best half about this tweet is that he contains actually no commentary as as to if that is good/dangerous/okay and but the entire replies are both ‘haha yeah pop music dangerous’ or ‘music critics are so dumb simply take heed to music ugh’
andrew is a genius
— Markothy (@_markothy_) September 17, 2020
Try extra replies beneath.
It isn’t the identical 4 notes essentially trigger they be in numerous keys however he does have a favourite development, and a variety of artists do, since music is math and there is solely so many combos that sound pleasing to Western ears en masse tl;dr he bought a formulation, and it is good.
— Craig Bro Dude (@CraigSJ) September 17, 2020
— to uproxx.com